Lapsed donor reactivation works best as a distinct, segmented campaign rather than folding lapsed donors into a standard annual appeal. Catapult's Donor Engagement methodology builds a specific "Reactivate" segment, typically donors whose most recent gift was a meaningful amount but given many months or years ago, and reaches them with a personalized, multi-touch sequence: a preferred-channel message, a genuine thank-you call for their past support, and a personal invitation to re-engage.
In a documented case for a faith-based organization, that Reactivate segment alone achieved a 32% higher response rate than the organization's historical benchmark, without discounting the ask or resorting to generic "we miss you" messaging.
The common mistake is treating a lapsed donor's silence as disinterest rather than as a signal that the last stewardship touch didn't land, most lapsed donors respond well to being thanked and asked again, just not with the same message that didn't work the first time.
More on Donor Acquisition & Retention